“Please Don’t Tell My Family!”: Helping Patients Face Lung Cancer Stigma

“Please Don’t Tell My Family!”: Helping Patients Face Lung Cancer Stigma

Guest Commentary

Dec 17, 2018

Dr. Narjust DumaBy Narjust Duma, MD

“Please don't tell my family,” Mary* immediately asked me after I disclosed the results of her lymph node biopsy and diagnosis of metastatic non-small cell lung cancer. At the time, I was a first-year oncology fellow. Initially, I thought it was a normal reaction (an example of my lack of experience). I respected her wishes and only disclosed to her family that she had metastatic cancer. I thought, it’s her right to decide how much they know. Hours later, when I presented the case to my attending, she was surprised about the patient’s request but honored it as I had done it earlier.

Mary was a 43-year-old woman, never smoker, active runner, wife, and mother. During our work-up, we discovered her lung cancer was EGFR-mutant and after a thoracentesis, she was discharged home. One week later, I saw her in the clinic for the first time; she came to the visit alone. I asked, “How is the family?” She stated, “They are better not knowing.” Over the following weeks we talked on the phone frequently as she was experiencing adverse events from erlotinib, and little by little our relationship grew.

We approached the first set of scans, and her disease was progressing; she was once again alone during the visit. After we shared the bad news and mourned for 15 minutes, I asked again about her family. In tears, she shared, "I do not want them to know I have lung cancer. I do not want our neighbors to know. I can't deal with their judgment."

I was stunned. She was afraid of the stigma associated with lung cancer.

She benefited from second-line therapy for 6 months. We discussed many times her fear of disclosing her diagnosis to her family; we incorporated psychology and palliative medicine to our team. Her family now knew that her cancer started in “the chest” but the words lung cancer were never said. She shared with us stories of members of her church and school that were diagnosed with lung cancer, judged and forgotten by the community.

We started platinum doublets. She progressively became weaker, scans only showed progression, and after a few months and some immunotherapy I saw her deteriorate and lose weight. Her family started coming to the oncology visits. Every time before our visits she would give me a piece of paper on which she’d written, “Please don’t tell my family.” Those words continue to follow me to this day.

On a Thursday night, I received a call from Mary’s oldest son that she was in the ER due to confusion; she was febrile and with progressing brain metastases. I thought to myself, “Her diagnosis will be disclosed now." Little did I know that Mary had planned for this ahead of time, enlisting her sister—her best friend—as her ally. Her sister rushed to the ER and asked physicians to avoid using the words "lung cancer." While in the hospital, Mary and I met a few times; we cried, laughed, and hugged. We knew she was reaching the end of her journey. She transferred to hospice care and died peacefully at home a few weeks later.

During her journey, I developed a strong relationship with her family, especially her sister. During the funeral, she told me that only Mary’s closest family (her husband and children) knew about her diagnosis of lung cancer.

One day while opening mail, I got a copy of Mary’s obituary. It described her as a "loving wife, mother, and sister” who “died of breast cancer,” and explained that the family had donated to a breast cancer-related charity. Almost immediately I started crying; my dear patient had to spend her last days carrying a lie because of the stigma associated with this disease. That moment, and Mary herself, ultimately changed my career path. In the past few years many patients have shared the stigma they encounter when disclosing their diagnosis of lung cancer.

Social media has helped connect patients with lung cancer; groups like the EGFResisters and foundations like Breath of Hope provides patients a safe place and an accepting community.

Lung cancer is the number one cancer killer in the United States and represents 14% of all cancers in the country. Advances in treatment have improved the survival of patients with lung cancer, but we still have a lot of work to do, especially in how this cancer is seen in the community. Stigma surrounds the disease and judgment is experienced frequently.  It’s time to change the face of lung cancer!

*Name and details changed for privacy.

Dr. Duma is the chief hematology/medical oncology fellow at Mayo Clinic in Rochester, MN. Her clinical and research interests include thoracic oncology, women with lung cancer, and the stigma surrounding the disease. Follow her on Twitter @NarjustDuma.  


The ideas and opinions expressed on the ASCO Connection Blogs do not necessarily reflect those of ASCO. None of the information posted on ASCOconnection.org is intended as medical, legal, or business advice, or advice about reimbursement for health care services. The mention of any product, service, company, therapy or physician practice on ASCOconnection.org does not constitute an endorsement of any kind by ASCO. ASCO assumes no responsibility for any injury or damage to persons or property arising out of or related to any use of the material contained in, posted on, or linked to this site, or any errors or omissions.


Diane M Dragaud, MA

Jan, 22 2019 4:46 PM

Thank you for sharing this story, Dr. Duma. It is an eloquent reminder to us, not only of the stigma that many patients with lung cancer must deal with, but also a shout out to some great advocacy organizations that are provind 'safe haven' communities to help patients cope. 

Back to Top